Feedback on my idea/startup/website/name questions have been deemed off-topic for this site. New questions related to these topics are closed, but we still have some old questions lingering on the site that should be closed. We should close them to avoid confusion among our new users that may take these open questions as an indicaton that they are on-topic.
Most of these feedback questions were tagged with ask-onstartups, review, or ideas. In phase 1 we looked at the ask-onstartups and review tags. In phase 5 we will finish this off by looking at questions tagged ideas.
We need to go through these tags and vote to close the off-topic questions. To make it easier and minimize the need to revisit valid questions, this is how it will work:
I posted an answer to this thread that contains links to the questions tagged with ideas. Pick a question from the list, and perform one of the following actions.
- If the question has already been closed or deleted, delete the link from the list.
- If it is a valid on-topic question, delete the link from the list.
- If the question is off-topic, vote to close and leave the link in the list for others to find.
This phase will last 1 week, starting today and ending on February 26. At the end of this phase all the links should have been deleted from the answer.
You need a minimum of 500 rep to have the ability to vote to close questions. For those that have less than 500 rep, you can still participate by leaving comments if you feel a question should be closed as off-topic, and by removing the already closed and deleted threads from the list in the answer below. Removing the closed/deleted threads from the list is actually quite helpful because it helps the higher rep users concentrate on the open questions.